“Who Is the Believer?” Everyday Typifications of “Us” and “Them” in Orthodox Christian and Muslim Discourses: The Case of Kazan
1/2010
Published in Russian, see Russian pages of this website.
SUMMARY:
The authors analyze the construction of their imagined communities of believers by the Russian Orthodox and Muslim priesthood of Tatarstan. The discussion is based on a series of interviews conducted with those priests and mullahs in Kazan who exercise authority among their parishioners, are actively engaged in communal work and education, and teach in the religious education establishments. They are characterized in the article as the “opinion leaders,” and their rhetoric of inclusion and exclusion is scrutinized in a comparative perspective. Khodzhaeva and Shumilova demonstrate that ethnic categories are integrated into the studied religious discourses and are used to symbolically broaden the communities of coreligionists. The language of priests and mullahs includes mundane ethnic stereotypes colored by a specific intolerance rooted not in religious but in current social-political discourses and practices. While interreligious dialogue is a steady feature of the Kazan religious environment, the dialogue and the convergence of opinions become most intense when it comes to the construction of common enemies exemplified by Western liberalism, globalization/cosmopolitanism, and cultural unification.
Notes
Н. Митрохин. Социальный лифт для верующих парней с рабочих окраин: епископат современной Русской Православной Церкви // Новые церкви, старые верующие – старые церкви, новые верующие / Под ред. К. Каарийнена, Д. Фурмана. Москва, Санкт-Петербург, 2007. С. 260-324; А. Красиков. Русская Православная Церковь: от “службы государевой” к испытанию свободой // Новые церкви, старые верующие. С. 134-259; С. В. Рыжова. Русское самосознание и этничность в православном дискурсе 90-х гг. // Религиозность и идентичность / Отв. ред. М. Т. Степанянц. Москва, 2003. С. 20-48.